The OECD Universal Basic Skills report (2015) compares the maths and science abilities of 15-year-old students in seventy-six countries1. This note examines Ireland’s performance relative to other high-income OECD countries2. Ireland’s performance is above average but significantly behind the top performing countries. It also has a significant number of underperforming students and this issue needs to be addressed.
Ireland is one of thirty-one countries in the OECD high-income category (hereafter OECD 31). The average score of students in Ireland was 512, which is above the OECD 31 average of 502. Ireland ranks 11th highest based on its average score for mathematics and science. The five countries with the highest average scores are: Korea (546), Japan (542), Finland (532), Estonia (531) and Switzerland (523). In contrast, the five lowest average scores are found in Chile (434), Greece (460), Israel (468), the Slovak Republic (476) and Sweden (482).
Table 1 shows the average score and percentage share of students achieving less than 420 points3 in the thirty-one high-income OECD countries.
Table 1 – Average score and share below 420 points (Countries ranked)
|Ranking||Country||Average Score||Ranking||Country||Share below 420 points (%)|
|17||United Kingdom||504||17||United Kingdom||19.6|
|24||United States||489||24||United States||23.5|
|28||Slovak Republic||476||28||Slovak Republic||28.8|
|OECD 31 average||502||OECD 31 average||20.1%|
(Source: OECD, 2015) *Ireland ranks joint 8th
Ireland’s share of students below 420 points at 15.1% is joint 8th lowest of the 31 countries. The Netherlands is also at 15.1%. The OECD 31 average is 20.1%, or one in five students. The five countries with the highest share of students below 420 points are Chile (45.3), Israel (32.7), Greece (32.5), Slovak Republic (28.8), and Sweden (26.1). Based on PISA criteria, these five high-income countries have more than a quarter of 15-year-olds who lack basic skills or are functionally illiterate in the modern economy. Conversely, the five countries with the lowest percentage of 15-year-olds who lack basic skills are Estonia (8.5), Korea (8.6), Japan (10.4), Finland (10.7) and Poland (12.7).
Mathematics was the main focus of the 2012 PISA tests. Ireland’s average maths score was 502, which is just above the average of 499 for high-income countries. Ireland’s maths ranking is 13th. Irish boys scored on average 15.3 points higher than girls in maths (boys 509.0 and girls 493.7). The three highest maths scores are found in Korea (554), Japan (536) and Switzerland (531). Table 2 shows the maths ranking for the OECD 31.
Table 2 – Maths Score
|Ranking||Country||Maths score||Maths boys||Maths|
|OECD 31 average||499||504||493|
(Source: OECD, 2015)
Ireland’s science performance is higher than its mathematics equivalent. Ireland ranks within the top ten in science at 9th place. With a score of 522 points, it is higher than the average of 505 for the OECD 31. Boys are performing marginally better at science than girls in Ireland (boys 523.9, girls 520.0). The three highest science scores are found in Japan (547), Finland (545) and Estonia (541).
Table 3 – Science score
|OECD 31 average||505||506||505|
(Source: OECD, 2015)
While the performance of Irish students in PISA 2012 was better than in 2009, there remain various areas for improvement. Ireland’s average scores in maths and science were higher than the OECD averages; however, maths performance needs to be increased if we are to remain above the OECD 31 average. Furthermore, 15.1% – one in seven – students failed to attain the basic skills score in Ireland. Although below the OECD average, this figure represents the modern functional illiteracy of a significant cohort of 15-year-olds in Ireland.
1 The report combines PISA (Programme for International Student Assessment) (2012) and TIMSS (Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study) (2011). The PISA 2015 assessments took place in Ireland in March 2015 and the major domain was science. The results will be made available in December 2016
2 Hungary, Mexico and Turkey are in the upper-middle income category and therefore are excluded.
3 A score below 420 points represents a lack of basic skills. The OECD states that basic skills are “at least Level 1 skills (420 points) on the OECD PISA” scale. This level of skills corresponds to what might today be called “modern functional literacy” (OECD, 2015: 15).